Workers who feel they have autonomy, that they are free to make choices in the workplace and be accountable for them, are happier and more productive according to an extensive research review. Yet there’s no universal cross-cultural definition of autonomy.
What people from one culture perceive as workplace freedom, those from another may view as simple disorganization. This is one of the conclusions of a chapter featured in a new book on workplace autonomy, Human Autonomy in Cross-Cultural Context: Perspectives on the Psychology of Agency, Freedom, and Well-Being, that’s coauthored by professors Marylène Gagné and Devasheesh Bhave from Concordia’s John Molson School of Business in Montréal, Québec.
“Autonomy is important in every culture,” said Gagné, about her chapter entitled, "Autonomy in the Workplace: An Essential Ingredient to Employee Engagement and Well-Being in Every Culture?" "The perception of autonomy has very positive effects on workers. However, managers can’t simply export North American methods of granting autonomy anywhere and expect them to work.”
Autonomy can take many different forms. Organizations may let employees set their own schedules, choose how to do their work or even elect to work from home. No matter how autonomy is defined, when people feel they have latitude the results are impressive. Potential benefits include greater employee commitment, better performance, improved productivity and lower turnover.
“Autonomy is especially likely to lead to better productivity when the work is complex or requires more creativity,” Gagné said. “In a very routine job, autonomy doesn’t have much impact on productivity, but it can still increase satisfaction, which leads to other positive outcomes. When management makes decisions about how to organize work, they should always think about the effect on people’s autonomy.”
Paradoxically, some employers are now actually reducing workers’ autonomy by monitoring behavior on workplace computers, or even on the phone or in the car. It’s another reason, Gagné says, why cartoons like Dilbert are so popular.
“They strike a responsive chord in many people, because they show what the work environment has become for some individuals,” she said.
With the workplace constantly evolving and globalization increasingly important, cross-cultural research into workplace autonomy is more important than ever. Until recently, most management research was conducted in North America. As a result, managers in other countries have little to guide them as they develop techniques that work in their own cultural context.
To help address this lack, Gagné is now studying leadership behavior in several countries including China and Italy.
“We’re trying to see how leadership behaviors affect employee motivation and if the same behaviors in different countries have the same effect,” Gagné said. “Sometimes, they do not. For example, in some cultures, bosses can’t ask the opinion of subordinates, because it makes them appear weak. So managers in these environments have to find other ways to make people feel autonomous. There is no simple recipe.”
(Story materials provided by Concordia University.)